Was The Virgin Birth And Other Christian Ideas Ripped Off From Pagan Mystery Religions?
This is a common objection raised in pop culture today. This information, however, is based on several erroneous assumptions.
1. Old Testament Prophecy
The virgin birth was prophesied 700 years before Jesus was born in Bethlehem. This prophecy pre-dates any of the pagan stories.
2. Skeptics Are Misreading Both Accounts While Mixing And Matching
Many of the popular writers who argue that Christianity borrowed from paganism are taking Christian theology, and reading it into the pagan mystery religions. For example, some claim that the pagan God Mithras sacrificed himself for peace just like Jesus. The actual teachings about Mithras, however, don’t say that. All they mention is the practice of sacrificing a bull, and being bathed in its blood. It was apparently part of the initiation rights underwent by new converts into the cult. This practice has nothing to do with what Christians believe the blood of Jesus accomplishes for believers. It is reading Christian theology into the stories about Mithras.
3. The Bible Was There First
The third mistake made by some of those writers who claim that Christianity copied its belief’s from other mystery religions is this: many of the Pagan religious texts, where vague parallels between their teachings and Christianity exist, are written over a hundred years after the Christian Gospels were written. Now think about that for a minute. If the pagan religious texts were written after the teachings of Christianity, who would be copying whom? The pagans were copying the Christians, not the other way around.
4. Christian Doctrine And Pagan Mythology Don’t Mix
Some of the apparent similarities are just plain fiction often propagated by those who haven’t read the Christian teachings or the pagan teachings very closely. For instance, some claim that the pagan God Mithras was born of a virgin in a cave, just like Jesus. When you actually read the story of Mithras’ birth, you find that he was actually born out of a rock and a shepherd had to pull him out. How that relates to the virgin birth of Jesus, I don’t know. I guess the rock was a virgin….
Researcher, Gretchen Passantino, says that the birth of Christ is radically different than various mythological tales.
“Instead of a virgin willingly conceiving by the invisible power of God, the myths give us lurid tales of lusty gods having forced sex with women… instead of the incarnation, the myths gave us half human, half divine super heroes subject to the same weaknesses, sins, and frustration as we are.”
5. Devout Jews Were Not Allowed To Mix Their Stories
Jews wrote the biblical Gospels. The Jewish people at the time of the writing were, for the most part, fiercely resistant to pagan ideas and concepts.
If you’ve heard that critique of the Christmas story before I hope the above helps.
Happy Christmas.